Simplicity of Musical Style in Corporate Worship
(By: John Miller)
My wife and I are lovers of music. We thank the Lord that He created music and has given it to us to enjoy. We both enjoy listening to music, and we both enjoy (at least attempting) to make music. She plays the piano, and I play the guitar, and we both love to sing. We are both musical, though my wife is far more musical than I am! (After all, she is the one who was a music major in college and taught elementary school music for three years after we were first married!) Needless to say, we enjoy music, and we take pleasure in various styles of music at that. We can delight in the intricacies of Mozart and enjoy the simplicity of the children’s songs we sing with our three year old daughter. Most of all, we delight in singing the praises of God with His people in corporate worship. But this has also been the occasion of great grief in our hearts, especially when we witness the people of God fighting with one another over this issue and causing dissension and division in the church of Jesus Christ. The worship wars, beloved, should not be! Yet the issue of music in worship has been the circumstance through which selfishness, hatred, jealousy, envy, anger, rage, malice and all manner of sins of the heart have come to be expressed among the people of God. Oh, may the Lord have mercy, and first forgive us of our sins and sanctify our hearts! Then may the Lord give us wisdom, especially those of us with the responsibility of leading the people of God in worshipping God through song.
It is in this area of wisdom that I believe it is helpful to listen and learn from those who have gone before us. What have they said about issues of musical style in worship? With this thought in mind, allow me to leave you with a quote from Edward T. Hiscox, a baptist pastor who lived from 1814-1901. While you may not agree with everything that he says, learn from him what you can and will. The following quote is taken from his work Principles and Practices for Baptist Churches, published in 1893.
Since the true idea of sacred song is that the people shall worship, not witness a performance, therefore the style of music should be such as the people can perform. But the mass of worshipers can never go beyond the simplest elements of any art or science; therefore the music for Christian service should be of the simplest kind, in structure and execution, and limited to a small number of tunes. Music more complicated in structure, and more artistic in execution, a few could perform, and perhaps more highly enjoy; but it could not express the devotion of the great majority of worshipers because they could not unite in it. Devotion seeks plain choral harmonies in which to utter its worship.
The leaders of Church music will be constantly endeavoring to treat the congregation to a greater variety in style and execution; but this will be a departure from the true idea of worship. As our religious services are usually arranged it may be very well to introduce them with an anthem, a chant, or a sentence by the choir; and possibly a short set piece somewhere before the sermon; perhaps immediately following the “long prayer,” but before the notices, and the second hymn. But the hymns – and the prevailing custom calls for three – should be sung to simple music, so familiar that the people can sing them, without an effort to remember the tune, and without danger of losing it, all thought being given to the sentiment and spirit of the words.
Lord, may you continue to grow us to be more like your Son, the Lord Jesus Christ, in love, wisdom, and grace, even in this area of music in your church. Amen.




Each month at Grace Covenant Church a different hymn is featured and sung every Sunday for that month. Usually the goal is for the congregation to learn new hymns or be exposed to old ones. For this month we have been singing “Lift Up Your Heads, Ye Mighty Gates” from the 
The discovery of true Christian worship shook my world as a young believer. And as I’ve shared what I learned since then, it has shaken the worlds of many other Christians as well. It has been a good thing. In fact, it has been a life-giving thing. That’s not to say that my understanding of true Christian worship isn’t controversial – it is. But like many things, it’s controversial because we are quick to believe what we hear without questioning its logic and comparing it with the Scriptures. So what do I mean by “true Christian worship”?